I picked this random product from one of your stores and was able to find it in the MP with various different searches using specific keywords in your tags + binder. I think this particular design is really cool which is why it caught my eye as one to try and search for. But your keywords are a bit limited.
joni warden
leather
belt
buckle
old leather
worn leather
rugged
strong
durable cowboy
wild west
You're only using 86 of the characters available to you. Here's a tag set I wrote up of 315 characters, Not saying these are great tags, just an example of how you can get much more out of them. Your tags and title keywords are the only way people will find your product in the MP; if you're not making the best of them you're limiting your exposure.
brilliant blue faux leather binder
old worn leather look design
deep royal blue distressed texture
rustic leather belt buckle strap
ornate classic gold filigree accents
vintage ornate journal notebook
faux suede gothic diary
dark academia style personal binder
grimoire book of magic spells
design exclusively by joni warden
Search for 'leather binder' or 'blue binder' or "blue leather binder' and look at how the top results tag their products. Many, including Gold & Platinum level sellers, include a use-case in their tags such as 'for attorney' or 'for law firm' etc..... Who's your target audience? Is there a specific use-case you could include in your tags?
I looked at the tags on some of your other products that caught my eye and think you have some really lovely work, just need to try to maybe up you tag game so you can be better found.
