- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Inappropriate Content
10-28-2025 05:24 AM
Et voilà ! I created a product specifically for a client, I sent him the link directly, I made the sale. and in my statistics it appears as a "3rd party". If further proof were needed that sales statistics are false.
Solved! Go to Solution.
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Inappropriate Content
10-28-2025 08:43 AM
While it is not fun to have happen. If they had already clicked on a Zazzle referral link prior to working with you, that would account for why. A new referral cannot override an existing one if it is in the cookie window.
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Inappropriate Content
10-28-2025 05:33 AM
I agree with you that this should NOT be allowed to happen.
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Inappropriate Content
10-28-2025 08:43 AM
While it is not fun to have happen. If they had already clicked on a Zazzle referral link prior to working with you, that would account for why. A new referral cannot override an existing one if it is in the cookie window.
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Inappropriate Content
10-28-2025 10:19 AM
I understand that, but the cookie window is too long (14 days, if I remember correctly).
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Inappropriate Content
10-28-2025 10:23 AM
Thank you for your answer, that's make sense!
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Inappropriate Content
10-28-2025 03:18 PM - edited 10-28-2025 03:24 PM
Then they need to find a way to provide a custom order to a customer that does override it. I am sorry but clicking an ad from Zazzle (the most likely 3rd party "referrer") or even someone else on Pinterest does not equate to the work we put in a custom order 😔💔 I don't know how to code obviously but it's 2025 and I can't believe they can't add a tag to the hidden items url that overwrites any cookies (same way %r tags a referral, %h = hidden listing that can only count as a self referral.
If that is not possible coding wise, maybe a separate option when creating the product where it says "Public, private, hidden" add "custom". Also only available to customers with the url and exempt from 3rd party referrals. Can't make it exempt from 3rd party referrals? Then tack on a custom order % bonus.
There has to be something 🙁💔 I enjoy helping people create and modify something so that they'll never say "I wish I would have changed this" once it's in their hands. I want them to absolutely love their end product and have it be everything they hoped. But my heart just drops every time. 1/10 of my last orders I have provided a custom url to after helping them create something special have counted as self referrals.
I grasp the concept of being rewarded for bringing people to the site, they should be. But no one can convince me the majority of these 3rd party sales aren't Zazzle. I have thousands and thousands of affiliate links on blogs & 2 different Pinterest accounts, pinned manually (with many "viral" Zazzle pins). I often run ads on multiple platforms to my Zazzle products and I RARELY get a referral for someone buying from someone else or for "self" 😓 Something about the system is so off and they don't seem to care. It feels like what's really happening is Zazzle gets 50% of every sale for "marketing" then uses that marketing to get 35% more as the referrer. Leaving us just hoping for customers who haven't clicked an ad or promotional email in 14 days 🙄 A vicious cycle 💔 I remember just a short year ago when notifications gave me excitement and I checked Zazzle every day. I am losing all heart and have been focusing efforts elsewhere. They are going to lose what is special about this platform... and they don't seem to care 🙁
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Inappropriate Content
10-28-2025 06:33 PM
I understand the frustration of Designer's helping customers personalize something and not getting any extra compensation for it. But 1), the referral system was never intended to be a means of securing extra payment for custom work and 2) the entire Z platform is based on shoppers being able to customize things themselves with NO limits (outside of what the designer may have intentionally limited such as by "locking" a layer etc..) If a shopper wants such extreme changes that they can't or aren't wiling to do themselves, then they either need to be looking for a different design that does suit their needs, or be willing to enter into a custom work contract with you outside of the Z platform.
An option to set things as "custom" so not subject to the referral system rules, that would be ripe for abuse. There'd be no reason to share something as anything but "custom".
It's often said that Z has THE best design tool of any POD (agreed!) but that's not just for Designers when creating - shoppers have the same extreme editing capabilities, beyond any other site I've seen. The more we cater to people wanting "tweaks" on a design, the more we dilute the intent of the platform & what sets it apart from others - to give shoppers the ability to fully customize on their own. If they want an extreme change that can't be achieved using the features they already have at their disposal, it's not Zazzle's responsibility to pay the Designer extra if/when they choose to placate a customer by doing extra for them.
I know this is an unpopular opinion but doing "custom work" for a potential customer is a choice one makes in hoping to cement a sale. Zazzle is not obligated to pay you extra for your choice. And even if they did, we have to remember that a sale can be cancelled at anytime so even if you are awarded extra by Z for custom work, the customer can cancel at any time and POOF! your extra time & effort was wasted anyway. Best thing would be to set up a revisions contract and payment terms for it outside of Z before sending them a link to their custom-designed product on Z. That way you are getting paid for your time & effort regardless of if they cancel the order or decide not even to go through with it to begin it, and regardless of whether it comes in as Self or 3rdP. You're still getting compensated for what you decided your time was worth.
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Inappropriate Content
10-28-2025 07:12 PM
Thanks for your detailed response but like I mentioned, I am aware this is not what the referral system was designed for 💖 As someone who was a customer first, I personally would have ended the transaction right there if asked to pay an additional fee outside of the platform I contacted the artist on. Especially when Zazzle puts the contact right there for them! And as a seller, I think that is tacky to ask. If someone offers to pay via PayPal, Venmo or another means I always appreciate skipping the platform fees and the ability to tip. But I would *personally* never ask. To each their own!
If I wanted to set up agreements and terms I would be on fivver doing custom work. That isn't what we are talking about here. We are talking about customers that reach out in regards to a design they already love and need help with. Not everything can be changed with Zazzles "5 star POD editing system". And not every customer has the ability. Do you know how many nice old ladies know how to edit? Unfortunately it's not the majority. In fact the number of customers I have that still order things without changing the name despite it being right there on the main page under "Personalize it" and giving them a big pop up when they don't change anything.... is mind boggling. Every customers needs and abilities are different and you seem to just be bunching them into one. Or your suggestion was that they need to find another design they don't want to change....essentially telling me to send the sale elsewhere instead of helping them? lol
Again, I completely understand your entire point. But it basically comes off as "sucks to be you, don't take custom work then". And that is just silly. I enjoy helping people and want to be the one that helps make their celebration everything they dreamed of. I don't think it's an unreasonable ask to ask that Zazzle at least pretend to value my time, artistry and customer service as well. Lately it just hasn't been feeling like that in multiple ways 💔 I think we are just very different styles of sellers and that is okay!
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Inappropriate Content
10-29-2025 12:14 AM
I’m a little old lady (it can be argued whether I’m sweet or not), and I can design - and use the design tool like a “mother.”
I’m also a retired professional designer who made a living for 40 years designing all sorts of things for private and commercial clients. Securing additional fees for requests to complete work outside the scope of the contract (in this case outside Zazzle’s terms and conditions) is always done through a payment system similar to that which ColsCreations mentioned above. It’s not icky, it’s standard practice.
However, in my experience - even with the extra payment - it’s usually not worth my time to take on this type of work. That’s why I don’t do custom work (except for family). But I still feel strongly that the 14-day cookie that Zazzle has implemented with the Ambassador program allows third parties to have an unfair advantage and it discredits designers’ work. No doubt about that.
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Inappropriate Content
10-29-2025 02:02 PM
Oh my gosh, I'm sorry, I did not mean "it sucks to be you". 😮
But I did mean that it's every Designer's choice as to how much they're willing to do to cement a sale.
Zazzle is known as a place where one can by themselves customize any of thousands of "templates" (or even make their own design from scratch). It's not a site for hiring a professional artist/graphic designer to do custom work for you at rock-bottom price or for free. I hesitate to say this as this is a publicly accessible forum, but, it is mind-boggling how clueless & entitled customers can be. I read the many comments from those of you who are constantly fielding chat messages from customers and it's sometimes shocking what they expect you to do for them as if it's a service included in the price listed on the page. If you (used in the general sense) consider yourself a professional and approach Zazzling as a serious business, you should not have a problem with requiring the customer to pay you for any additional services you provide for them. If you (again, used in the general sense) want to do the extra work for free to establish good customer relations, that's on you. And even if Z did set up some way to compensate designers for custom work on top of the regular royalty earnings, I can't think of any system that wouldn't be wide-open to abuse by every designer on the platform.
Also, no, I didn't mean you should be referring customers to other designs. What I meant was, if the design requires such extensive modification that the customer can't manage it themselves, then the customer should keep looking for something closer to what they actually want. It just seems very entitled to me to ask the designer to make something special without offering from the get-go, before even being asked, to pay for that special service
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Inappropriate Content
10-29-2025 01:18 AM
Thank you very much for your reply. I doubt Zazzle will make any effort with coding, as long as the "3D party" allows them to save on royalties paid to creators.